The Paradox of Influence: Unpacking the Success of Social Media Personalities Amidst Non-Traditional Trajectories and Controversial Conduct

The social influencers mentality

Section 1: Understanding Social Influence: Theoretical Frameworks

The phenomenon of social influence, wherein individuals' thoughts, feelings, and behaviors are shaped by others, is central to understanding the power wielded by social media influencers. This influence manifests in various forms and is driven by fundamental psychological needs and mechanisms.

1.1 Core Models of Social Influence: Conformity, Compliance, and Obedience

Social influence can be broadly categorized into three primary types: conformity, compliance, and obedience.1

• Conformity describes behavioral changes enacted to align with a group or match the responses of others.1 It is often a subtle pressure, driven by the assumption that if many people are doing something, it must hold value or be correct.1 Classic research by Solomon Asch demonstrated that individuals might knowingly provide incorrect answers to conform with a group consensus, highlighting a willingness to "go along".1 Conformity is an implicit expectation, an unspoken rule enforced by group norms, and it begins early in life, with infants imitating others.3 Social norms, or group norms, dictate expected behavior in specific situations, with an implied payoff for adherence, such as group acceptance and increased chances of finding a life partner.3

• Compliance involves behavioral changes in direct response to a request, whether explicit or implicit.1 Unlike conformity, compliance is an explicit expectation, clearly and formally stated.3 The "foot-in-the-door" technique, where agreement to a small initial request increases the likelihood of agreeing to a larger subsequent request, exemplifies compliance.1 This is rooted in the human tendency to act consistently with past behaviors.1

• Obedience is a change in behavior in response to a direct order or command from an authority figure.1 The Milgram experiments are a classic illustration, showing individuals' willingness to administer perceived harmful electric shocks when instructed by an authority, underscoring a deep-seated tendency to obey authority, which is seen as crucial for societal functioning.1 Obedience is also an explicit expectation, often accompanied by potential social punishment for non-compliance.3

Individuals are susceptible to these forms of influence for several overarching reasons: the need to choose correctly (using social cues as a shortcut for decision-making), the desire to gain social approval (as exclusion is evolutionarily dangerous), and the drive to manage one's self-image and appear likeable.1 Personality traits such as agreeableness (Interpersonal Sensitivity) and conscientiousness (Prudence) also correlate with susceptibility to social influence.1

1.2 Kelman's Varieties and Deutsch & Gerard's Dual Needs

Harvard psychologist Herbert Kelman, in 1958, identified three broad varieties of social influence that offer a more granular understanding:

• Compliance: Public agreement with others while privately maintaining dissenting opinions. The satisfaction from compliance stems from the social effect of accepting influence, often for an expected reward or to avoid punishment.2

• Identification: Influence accepted from a liked and respected individual, such as a celebrity or a popular influencer. Individuals adopt the behavior or attitude because it is associated with the attractive source and helps maintain a satisfying self-defining relationship with that source.2

• Internalization: Public and private acceptance of a belief or behavior because it is intrinsically rewarding and congruent with one's value system.2 Informational conformity, or social proof, aligns with Kelman's concept of internalization.2

Morton Deutsch and Harold Gerard further elaborated on the motivations behind conformity by describing two fundamental psychological needs 2:

• Informational Social Influence (Need to be Right): Individuals conform because they believe others have accurate information, accepting it as evidence about reality. This is also known as social proof.2

• Normative Social Influence (Need to be Liked): Individuals conform to meet the expectations of others to gain social approval and avoid rejection.2

These models highlight that social influence is not monolithic but operates through different psychological processes depending on the context and the individual's motivations, such as forming accurate perceptions, developing social relationships, and maintaining a favorable self-concept.4

1.3 Cialdini's "Weapons of Influence" and Social Impact Theory

Robert Cialdini identified six "weapons of influence," or principles of persuasion, that describe common psychological triggers for compliance and behavioral change 2:

1. Reciprocity: People feel obliged to return favors. Influencers may offer exclusive content or discounts, creating a sense of obligation in followers.2

2. Commitment and Consistency: Once individuals commit to an idea or behavior, they are averse to changing their minds without good reason, striving for consistency.2 Followers engaging with an influencer over time become more likely to align their purchasing behavior with recommendations.5

3. Social Proof: People are more open to actions they see others doing. The popularity of an influencer or their recommendations serves as social proof.2

4. Authority: People tend to obey authority figures or those perceived as experts. Influencers often position themselves as authorities in their niche.2

5. Liking: People are more easily persuaded by those they like. This is closely tied to the parasocial relationships influencers develop with followers.2

6. Scarcity: Perceived limitations in resources or opportunities generate demand. Influencers often use limited-time offers or exclusive products to prompt quick action.2 A seventh principle, Unity (shared identity), is also sometimes included, emphasizing that we are more influenced by those we perceive as part of "us".6

Social Impact Theory posits that the likelihood of an individual responding to social influence increases based on three factors 2:

• Strength: The importance or power of the influencing group or individual.

• Immediacy: The physical (or temporal) proximity of the influencing source at the time of the influence attempt.

• Number: The quantity of people in the influencing group.

Furthermore, influence is strongest when the source is consistent and committed; even a single dissenter can significantly weaken an influence.2 These frameworks provide a robust lens through which to analyze how social influencers, despite varying backgrounds or behaviors, effectively persuade and attract audiences.

The impact of social Media showing what you looking for based on your interest.

Section 2: The Financial Ascent of Social Influencers: Economic Models and Market Dynamics

The financial success of social media influencers is a multifaceted phenomenon driven by a burgeoning creator economy and sophisticated monetization strategies. This section examines the primary revenue streams available to influencers, the economic drivers underpinning their financial gains, and the increasing importance of performance measurement in this evolving market.

2.1 Primary Revenue Streams for Social Influencers

Social influencers have diversified their income beyond simple endorsements, creating a complex ecosystem of revenue generation. Key mechanisms include:

• Brand Partnerships and Sponsored Content: This remains a cornerstone of influencer income. Brands pay influencers to create and disseminate content—posts, videos, stories—featuring their products or services.7 The economic rationale for brands is to tap into the influencer's engaged and often niche audience, leveraging their credibility to boost brand awareness, foster audience engagement, and ultimately drive sales and revenue growth.7 Marketers report that sponsored content significantly outperforms organic brand content in engagement and conversions.7 Instagram is a dominant platform for these partnerships, with features like Collab Posts maximizing visibility.7

• Affiliate Marketing: Influencers promote products or services using unique, trackable links or discount codes, earning a commission on each sale generated through their referral.7 This model is particularly lucrative on platforms like TikTok (e.g., the #TikTokMadeMeBuyIt trend) and Instagram.7 It is a rapidly growing sector, expected to reach $36.9 billion by 2030, with influencers viewing it as a key income source, especially during peak promotional periods like Amazon Prime Day.8 This performance-based model incentivizes genuine endorsements as earnings are directly tied to audience purchasing decisions.7

• Merchandise Sales: Many influencers develop and sell their own branded merchandise, ranging from apparel and accessories to digital products like guides or presets.7 This revenue stream is fueled by the strong connection and loyalty influencers cultivate with their followers, who purchase merchandise to support their favorite creators and express their affiliation.7

• Ad Revenue: Platforms like YouTube share advertising revenue with creators based on content viewership and engagement metrics.7 Similarly, TikTok launched its Creator Fund in 2020, and subsequently the TikTok Creative Platform Beta, aiming to offer fairer remuneration to top creators, which is likely to attract more influencers.9

• Direct Fan Support and Subscriptions: Influencers are increasingly leveraging platforms like Patreon or native platform features (e.g., channel memberships on YouTube, subscriptions on Instagram) that allow audiences to directly support them through recurring payments, tips, or one-time contributions.7 This model often provides fans with exclusive content, personalized experiences, or a closer connection to the creator.7

• Other Revenue Avenues: These include fees for product reviews, long-term brand ambassadorships, and hosting giveaways or contests that boost engagement and brand awareness.8

The maturation of the influencer economy is evident in this shift from reliance on one-off brand deals to a more strategic, diversified approach to income generation. Early influencer marketing was often experimental and focused on brand awareness with less clear ROI.8 Today, the landscape is characterized by a strong emphasis on performance metrics, data-driven campaign strategies, and the influencer as a multifaceted entrepreneur.7 The integration of sophisticated tools, including AI for campaign optimization 9 and even academic game-theoretical models to analyze brand-influencer-platform dynamics 10, signals a move towards a more structured and accountable economic system. This professionalization may elevate barriers to entry but also promises more sustainable careers for those who successfully adapt.

2.2 Economic Drivers and Trends in the Creator Economy (including 2025 outlook)

The financial success of influencers is propelled by several key economic drivers and evolving market trends:

• High Return on Investment (ROI) and Engagement: Sponsored content is reported by 92% of marketers to outperform brands' organic content, with 90% stating it yields stronger engagement and 83% linking it to increased conversions.7 This effectiveness is a primary driver for continued brand investment. Nearly half of consumers report making daily, weekly, or monthly purchases based on influencer posts, and 86% make at least one such purchase annually.7

• Increased Marketing Budgets: Reflecting this confidence, 95% of marketing leaders intend to maintain or increase their influencer marketing budgets, recognizing it as a necessity rather than an experiment.7

• Authenticity and Credibility as Currency: Influencers often build genuine, trust-based relationships with their audiences, making their recommendations feel more authentic than traditional advertising.5 Approximately 69% of consumers trust influencer recommendations 9, and Gen Z, a key demographic, trusts influencers more than traditional celebrities.9

• Targeted and Niche Reach: Influencers frequently cultivate well-defined audience demographics, enabling brands to reach specific customer segments with greater precision.8 The rise of nano and micro-influencers, who have smaller but highly engaged and loyal followings, is a significant trend, valued for their authenticity and deeper audience connections.8

• Creators as Multifaceted Entrepreneurs: Successful influencers are no longer solely reliant on brand deals. They are diversifying income by leveraging subscriptions and affiliate commissions, which enhances their credibility and financial stability.8

• Social Commerce Integration: The growth of social commerce features like shoppable posts, live shopping events, and direct affiliate links within platforms allows influencers to drive sales more directly, making their marketing efforts more ROI-driven and measurable.8

• The Role of Artificial Intelligence (AI): AI is increasingly used in influencer marketing, with 38% of marketing professionals using it on a limited basis and 22% extensively. For 66% of marketers, AI integration improves campaign outcomes, aiding in influencer selection, content optimization, and performance analysis.9

• Platform Dynamics and Game Theory: Academic research is exploring the complex interactions within the influencer ecosystem using game-theoretical models. These models analyze optimal channel strategies for brands, considering factors like streaming costs, product value, and pricing strategies in relation to influencer channels.10 Such research indicates that while discounts on influencer channels can boost an influencer's profit in the short term, brand owners may adjust their own pricing strategies in the long run in response.10

A delicate balance of power exists between brands, influencers, and the platforms they inhabit. Brands rely on influencers for authentic engagement, while influencers depend on brands for revenue but must also protect their authenticity from overly restrictive partnerships.13 Platforms, like TikTok with its Creator Fund 9, attempt to incentivize creators but also exert control over the ecosystem and monetization. This symbiotic yet potentially tense relationship means that changes in platform algorithms or shifts towards over-commercialization can disrupt the ecosystem, impacting influencer income, perceived authenticity, and ultimately, brand ROI. The increasing popularity of direct fan support mechanisms 7 may represent a strategic move by influencers to mitigate dependency on both brands and platforms.

2.3 The Role of Performance Measurement and ROI in Influencer Marketing

As the influencer marketing industry matures, there is a pronounced shift from focusing on awareness-based metrics to demanding clear, attributable ROI.8

• Data-Driven Campaign Management: Brands and agencies are increasingly utilizing advanced analytics and attribution tools to assess which influencers genuinely drive revenue, customer acquisition, and long-term growth.8 This allows for more strategic investment in creators who demonstrably "move the needle".8

• Synergy of Influencer and Affiliate Marketing: The combination of influencer marketing with affiliate programs is a powerful trend. This approach offers performance-based compensation tied directly to sales and conversions, making campaigns more cost-effective and scalable.8 It also fosters stronger brand-influencer relationships, as incentives are aligned with tangible results.8

• Focus on Tangible Business Outcomes: The emphasis is moving beyond vanity metrics (like follower counts or likes) to track critical business indicators such as revenue generated, customer acquisition costs (CAC), and customer lifetime value (CLV).8 This requires sophisticated tracking methods and a commitment to data analysis to ensure investments yield meaningful results.

The paradox of authenticity in monetization is a critical consideration. Authenticity is consistently highlighted as a primary driver of an influencer's effectiveness and the trust they build.5 However, the very act of monetizing this influence through sponsored content, affiliate marketing, or merchandise sales can inherently challenge perceived authenticity if not managed with transparency and skill. As audiences become more discerning about these commercial relationships 15, the most successful influencers will be those who can adeptly navigate this paradox. They must integrate monetization efforts in a way that feels organic and does not alienate their audience or compromise their perceived genuineness. This may favor influencers who have cultivated strong parasocial bonds or those operating in niches where product recommendations are a natural and expected part of their content. Furthermore, the "self-made" narrative, often projected by influencers, might create an environment where audiences are more willing to accept overt monetization as a way to support the influencer's ongoing journey and success.

The following table summarizes the key revenue streams for social influencers and their underlying economic drivers:

Revenue Stream	Description	Key Economic Driver	Example Snippet ID(s)
Brand Partnerships	Brands pay influencers to create and promote content featuring their products/services.	Brand desire for authentic reach, engagement, and sales via trusted personalities.	7
Affiliate Marketing	Influencers earn commission on sales generated through unique trackable links or discount codes.	Performance-based sales; direct attribution of influencer effort to revenue.	7
Merchandise Sales	Influencers sell their own branded products (physical or digital) directly to their audience.	Fan loyalty, desire to support creators, and connection to the influencer's brand.	7
Ad Revenue	Platforms (e.g., YouTube, TikTok) share advertising revenue with creators based on viewership and engagement.	Platform monetization models rewarding content creation and audience engagement.	7
Direct Fan Support	Audiences directly pay creators via subscriptions, tips, or memberships for exclusive content/access.	Audience desire for deeper connection, exclusive content, and direct creator support.	7
Product Reviews	Influencers are paid to provide honest reviews of products.	Brands seeking credible third-party validation and detailed product exposure.	8
Brand Ambassadorships	Long-term partnerships where influencers regularly promote a brand.	Brands aiming for sustained association with an influencer and their audience.	8
Giveaways & Contests	Influencers host contests to boost audience participation, engagement, and brand awareness.	Brands seeking rapid engagement boosts and increased visibility.	8

This structured approach to revenue, coupled with a focus on measurable performance, underscores the transformation of influencer marketing into a significant and strategically managed sector of the digital economy.

Section 3: The Psychology of Influencer Attraction and Audience Engagement

The social magnetism of influencers stems from a complex interplay of psychological and sociological factors that foster deep connections with their audiences. Understanding these dynamics, including parasocial relationships, the perception of authenticity and relatability, and the fulfillment of fundamental human needs, is crucial to comprehending why influencers achieve such potent social attraction.

3.1 The Power of Parasocial Relationships (PSRs)

Parasocial relationships are one-sided psychological bonds where audience members develop illusions of intimacy, friendship, and identification with media performers, including social media influencers, following repeated exposure.16 These relationships are actively cultivated by media personas and platforms, often designed to mimic face-to-face interactions.16 Trust and self-disclosure by the influencer significantly enhance the development and strength of PSRs.16 Over time, the consistent consumption of an influencer's content leads followers to feel they genuinely "know" the persona, fostering a sense of familiarity and understanding.17

In the context of social media, PSRs are particularly potent and critical for an influencer's effectiveness.5 Platforms like Instagram, TikTok, and YouTube, with their interactive features such as likes, comments, and direct messages, amplify these connections, making influencers appear more like accessible friends than distant celebrities.17 This perceived friendship, even if illusory, significantly enhances follower loyalty and trust.20 Indeed, strong PSRs can sometimes lead to what researchers term "blind trust" in an influencer's recommendations.22

PSRs fulfill several important psychological needs for audience members. They can provide a sense of companionship, offer emotional support, and create a social connection without the risk of rejection inherent in real-life relationships.16 For individuals experiencing loneliness or social anxiety, these one-sided bonds can be particularly comforting.17 Moreover, PSRs can play a role in identity formation, as followers may look to influencers as role models or sources of inspiration.17 This dynamic extends even to virtual influencers, where cognitive and affective social identification with the influencer's follower group enhances PSRs, especially if the virtual influencer is human-like in appearance.24

3.2 Perceived Authenticity and Relatability

Perceived authenticity is a cornerstone of an influencer's appeal and their ability to build strong, trusting relationships with their audience.5 Authenticity is generally defined as the influencer being perceived as genuine, transparent, honest, and true to their own values and mission.5 This is particularly valued by younger audiences like Gen Z, who are adept at discerning genuine content from overly promotional messages.5 Influencers who share personal stories, engage with followers on a personal level, and are transparent about their partnerships are typically viewed as more trustworthy and credible.5 Research identifies five core properties contributing to perceived authenticity: expertise, connectedness (the emotional bond with the audience), originality of content, transparency (e.g., about sponsored content or AI use), and integrity (perceived motivations, such as passion over financial gain).13 Interestingly, an influencer doesn't necessarily need to exhibit all five; the presence of some can compensate for the absence of others.13

Relatability is closely intertwined with authenticity. Influencers achieve relatability by creating and sharing content that resonates with the experiences, values, and interests of their niche audiences.5 The principle of homophily, which suggests that individuals tend to bond with others who are similar in terms of beliefs, values, education, or social standing, plays a significant role here.14 When followers perceive an influencer as similar to themselves, it fosters a stronger connection and interaction.14 For instance, student influencers often gain traction due to the shared life stage with their predominantly student audience.29 Furthermore, influencers who share their vulnerabilities—personal adversities, insecurities, and challenges—can significantly enhance their relatability, presenting a more human and "less perfect" side that contrasts with idealized portrayals.28

Both authenticity and relatability have a profound impact on audience trust and subsequent purchase intentions. When followers perceive an influencer as genuine and trustworthy, their engagement with the content increases, and they are more likely to act on the influencer's recommendations.5

The drive for authenticity and the formation of PSRs are deeply connected. Audiences crave authenticity, and these PSRs are often built upon the perceived genuineness and relatability of the influencer. However, a fundamental tension exists because influencers are frequently monetizing these very relationships. The act of cultivating a "relatable" or "authentic" persona for financial benefit introduces an "Authenticity Paradox." The more genuinely an influencer appears, the stronger the PSR and the more potent their influence, yet this perceived authenticity might itself be a meticulously constructed performance. As noted, social media platforms can create "persuasive illusions of closeness and authenticity".21 This suggests that audiences might either be willingly suspending disbelief or may not fully perceive the performative aspect of influencer personas, raising questions about the true nature of these bonds and the potential for emotional leverage, especially when "blind trust" is established.22

3.3 Self-Determination Theory (SDT) and Influencer Appeal

Self-Determination Theory (SDT), proposed by Deci and Ryan, posits that human motivation is fundamentally driven by the satisfaction of three basic psychological needs: autonomy, competence, and relatedness.5 Social media influencers often appeal to audiences, particularly Gen Z, by catering to these needs:

• Autonomy: This refers to an individual's desire for control over their actions and decisions. Gen Z consumers, for example, prefer to make purchasing decisions that align with their personal values and lifestyles. Influencers who provide transparent, genuine content, rather than overtly promotional messages, respect this need for autonomy and are perceived as more credible.5

• Competence: This involves the need to feel effective and capable. Influencers often provide detailed product demonstrations, tutorials, or insightful information, thereby equipping their audience with the knowledge and tools to make informed and confident decisions.5

• Relatedness: This concerns the fundamental human need for connection and belonging. Influencers cultivate a sense of intimacy and trust with their followers, primarily through the mechanisms of parasocial relationships and by fostering a community atmosphere. This fulfills the audience's need for relatedness, further enhancing the influencer's credibility and impact.5

3.4 Social Comparison Theory: Aspiration, Envy, and Self-Esteem Effects

Festinger's Social Comparison Theory suggests that individuals have an innate drive to evaluate their own opinions and abilities by comparing themselves to others, particularly in situations of uncertainty or when objective measures are absent.31 Social media platforms, with their constant stream of curated self-presentations, have significantly amplified this tendency.31

• Upward Social Comparison: This occurs when individuals compare themselves to those they perceive as superior in some dimension (e.g., attractiveness, success, lifestyle). Influencers often present idealized versions of their lives, which can trigger upward social comparison in their followers. While this can sometimes be inspiring (the "assimilation effect," where individuals are motivated to achieve similar outcomes), it more frequently leads to negative psychological outcomes such as feelings of inferiority, envy, lower self-esteem, body image issues, and even mental health challenges like depression.19

• Downward and Lateral Social Comparison: Downward comparison (comparing to those perceived as worse off) can temporarily boost self-esteem, while lateral comparison (comparing to perceived equals) is common but can foster a competitive outlook.32

• Continued Engagement Despite Negative Feelings: Paradoxically, negative feelings like envy do not always lead to disengagement from influencer content. Envy itself has been identified as a motivation for following influencers.30 Furthermore, some individuals, particularly those with pre-existing low self-esteem, may engage more frequently in social comparison, potentially creating a negative feedback loop where they continue to consume content that makes them feel inadequate.32

Social comparison acts as a double-edged sword in the influencer ecosystem. While influencers' aspirational content can attract followers, it can also inadvertently (or sometimes intentionally) prey on audience insecurities. The "self-made" narrative often adopted by influencers might offer a perceived pathway to bridge the gap created by upward comparison, making the aspiration seem more attainable and thus maintaining engagement. However, the potential for detrimental mental health effects remains a significant concern.

3.5 Community Building and the Sense of Belonging

The human need for relatedness, as highlighted by SDT 5, and the principles of Social Identity Theory, which posits that individuals derive part of their identity from group memberships 34, underscore the importance of community in influencer appeal.

• Shared Identity and Values: Influencers who successfully cultivate communities around shared interests, values, or identities create strong bonds of loyalty that can transcend individual pieces of content.35 For example, travel influencers often construct their social identities through stages of transformation, maintenance, and value presentation, which helps them foster communities of like-minded followers.36

• Fanship and Fandom: Online fan communities provide members with social connectedness, a sense of belonging, and even collective resilience, all of which contribute to intense loyalty and engagement.37

• Platform Features for Community: Social media platforms and dedicated creator platforms offer numerous tools that facilitate community building and direct interaction. These include live streaming with real-time chat, Q&A sessions, polls, direct messaging, exclusive content for members, virtual gifts, and dedicated community spaces like Discord servers or Facebook groups.34 These features strengthen the influencer-audience dynamic and provide avenues for monetization through community engagement.

The true "stickiness" or enduring appeal of an influencer may lie less in their individual charisma and more in the strength, exclusivity, and sense of belonging fostered within the community they build. This transforms the influencer's role from a simple one-to-many broadcaster to an orchestrator of a many-to-many network, where the audience itself becomes a key asset and a source of shared identity and mutual reinforcement.

3.6 The Role of Entertainment Value

Beyond deep psychological connections, the sheer entertainment value provided by influencers is a significant factor in their appeal. Research indicates a strong association between the entertainment value of social media influencers and customer engagement.14 Influencers often provide content that is not only informative or aspirational but also enjoyable, comforting, or inspiring.42 Audiences frequently turn to influencer content specifically for entertainment or inspiration, highlighting this as a fundamental driver of their social attraction.28

The following table systematically breaks down the key psychological factors contributing to influencer attraction:

Psychological Factor	Description of its Role	Psychological Needs Fulfilled/Mechanisms	Key Snippet ID(s)
Parasocial Relationships (PSRs)	One-sided bonds of intimacy/friendship with influencers, fostered by repeated exposure and perceived self-disclosure.	Companionship, emotional support, identity formation, reduced risk of rejection, sense of knowing the influencer.	5
Perceived Authenticity	Influencer seen as genuine, transparent, honest, and true to their values; crucial for trust.	Builds trust, credibility; aligns with audience values, especially for Gen Z.	5
Relatability/ Homophily	Influencer shares similarities (experiences, values, background) with the audience, fostering connection.	Sense of being understood, validation of own experiences, stronger connection due to perceived similarity.	14
Self-Determination Needs (SDT)	Influencer content caters to audience needs for autonomy, competence, and relatedness.	Autonomy (control over choices), competence (feeling capable/informed), relatedness (connection/belonging).	5
Social Comparison	Audiences evaluate themselves against influencers' (often idealized) lives.	Self-evaluation; can lead to envy/low self-esteem (upward comparison) or inspiration (assimilation effect).	19
Community/ Belonging	Influencers cultivate groups with shared interests/identity, fostering loyalty.	Need for relatedness, social identity, sense of belonging, collective resilience, social support.	5
Entertainment Value	Influencer content provides enjoyment, amusement, inspiration, or comfort.	Diversion, pleasure, emotional stimulation, inspiration.	14

These psychological drivers, working in concert, explain the powerful social attraction influencers command, enabling them to build and maintain highly engaged audiences.

Section 4: Navigating the Paradox: Success Despite Perceived Deficiencies and Problematic Behaviors

A central question in the study of social media influencers is how many achieve significant financial success and social attraction despite apparent shortcomings, such as a lack of formal education, or engaging in social behaviors often deemed less acceptable, highly vocal, or overtly selfish. This section explores these paradoxes, examining the appeal of "self-made" narratives, anti-establishment personas, and the complex audience reactions to controversial actions.

4.1 The 'Self-Made' Narrative: Appeal of Non-Traditional Paths and Perceived 'Street Smarts'

The perceived lack of formal education in an influencer does not necessarily detract from their appeal and can, in some contexts, enhance it.

• Homophily and Relatability vs. Formal Expertise: The principle of homophily suggests that individuals are drawn to those who share similar characteristics, including educational background and social standing.14 For audiences who themselves may not have pursued higher education or who harbor skepticism towards academic institutions, an influencer without formal degrees might appear more relatable. This can create a stronger sense of connection than an expert with traditional credentials might achieve. While expertise, defined as knowledge and professional experience, is generally linked to credibility and purchase intention 14, the source of this perceived expertise can be varied.

• Authenticity of 'Lived Experience': Audiences, particularly younger demographics like Gen Z, place a high premium on authenticity.5 "Lived experience" shared genuinely by an influencer can often resonate more powerfully and be perceived as more trustworthy than formal, academic expertise, especially if the latter is seen as detached or unrelatable.27 For instance, an influencer who consistently creates content about skincare, sharing their personal journey and what has worked for them, can be perceived as authentic and credible in that niche, even if they are not a formally trained dermatologist.13 Their authority stems from demonstrated experience and consistent engagement with the topic.

• The Appeal of 'Street Smarts': The concept of "street smarts"—practical intelligence, resourcefulness, and the ability to navigate real-world challenges—can hold significant appeal, especially for youth who may value these attributes more highly than "book smarts" or formal academic achievements.45 Influencers who embody a "self-made" persona, demonstrating success achieved through practical experience, resilience, and an understanding of real-life complexities, can garner substantial trust and admiration from audiences who prioritize these qualities over formal credentials.45 This narrative of overcoming obstacles without traditional institutional backing can be highly inspirational.

• Storytelling as a Source of Authentic Leadership: "Self-made" influencers often leverage powerful storytelling techniques to narrate their journeys, including their struggles, failures, and ultimate successes.46 This authentic sharing of personal experiences can build a strong sense of leadership and credibility that is not reliant on traditional qualifications. Their story becomes their credential, fostering a deep connection with followers who may see their own aspirations reflected in the influencer's narrative.

The success of influencers lacking formal education often hinges on their ability to reframe this absence as a strength – a testament to their relatability, authentic lived experience, or practical "street smarts." This can foster a strong sense of homophily and parasocial connection, making the influencer appear more like "one of us" rather than an aloof expert or celebrity. Their journey, often characterized by overcoming odds, becomes a source of inspiration and a powerful component of their brand.

4.2 The Allure of the 'Anti-Establishment' and Vocal Personalities

Some influencers cultivate appeal by adopting an "anti-establishment" stance or by being exceptionally vocal, often challenging mainstream narratives or traditional forms of authority.

• Challenging Traditional Authority and Narratives: A willingness to amplify perspectives that contradict "official" or mainstream narratives can build significant credibility with audience segments that are skeptical of established institutions, media, or forms of expertise.49 By positioning themselves as outsiders or truth-tellers, these influencers tap into a desire for alternative viewpoints.

• The Appeal of Anti-Intellectualism: In some cases, influencers may contribute to a broader trend of anti-intellectualism, where subjective opinions or personal charisma are presented as equally or more valid than fact-based expertise.51 Fame and popularity can, for some followers, become conflated with correctness or authority, regardless of the influencer's actual knowledge base.51 This can involve a "dumbing-down" of complex issues, making them more digestible but potentially less accurate, and framing this simplification as a form of social justice against perceived "elitist" institutions.51

• Creation of Alternative Authority: Certain organizations or movements strategically utilize "influencer-intellectuals" who frame partisan or ideological arguments with the superficial trappings of scholarship, but without undergoing traditional academic peer review or validation.52 This tactic aims to create a sense of alternative authority that appeals to audiences seeking validation for pre-existing beliefs or those distrustful of mainstream academic and media institutions.

The appeal here often lies in providing a voice for dissent or a perceived authenticity that comes from challenging the status quo. Such influencers can become powerful figures for communities that feel ignored or misrepresented by traditional power structures.

4.3 Problematic Behaviors and Their Impact on Success

The success of some influencers occurs not just despite, but sometimes because of, behaviors that might be considered problematic, selfish, or controversial.

• 'Rage-Baiting' and the Outrage Economy: A notable "less acceptable but highly vocal" behavior is "rage-baiting," where influencers intentionally create and post content designed to provoke anger, outrage, or strong negative reactions to maximize views and engagement.15 This tactic is effective because social media algorithms often reward high engagement, regardless of the sentiment driving it (e.g., hate comments can boost visibility).53 This phenomenon is part of a broader "outrage economy," where provocative and controversial content is often more profitable because it captures attention, the primary currency of social media.54

• Narcissism, Selfishness, and Dark Triad Traits:

• Characteristics and Online Manifestation: Traits associated with the Dark Triad—Narcissism (characterized by grandiosity, entitlement, and a lack of empathy), Machiavellianism (manipulativeness, self-interest, and indifference to morality), and Psychopathy (impulsivity, thrill-seeking, and low empathy)—can manifest in influencer behavior.13 Narcissistic individuals, for example, frequently use social media as a platform for seeking validation, admiration, and reassurance.50 The pursuit of fame itself is linked to narcissistic tendencies, often mediated by problematic internet use, as the online world provides ample opportunity for self-promotion and attention-seeking.50 Behaviors like excessive selfie-posting have been shown to encourage narcissistic and selfish tendencies.58

• Audience Attraction to Negative Traits: Paradoxically, some of these negative traits can contribute to an influencer's allure. The superficial charm associated with psychopathy, the inflated egos and confidence of narcissists, or the strategic and sometimes ruthless misbehavior of Machiavellians might be perceived by certain audience segments as signs of strength, confidence, or shrewdness.56 Narcissistic leaders, often drawn to positions of power and influence, can attract followers, particularly those with lower self-esteem who may be seeking external validation or are drawn to charismatic, high-power individuals.59

• The "Dark Side" of Influencer Culture: Beyond personality traits, influencers may engage in a range of problematic behaviors, including promoting harmful products (e.g., unhealthy diet supplements), spreading misinformation, perpetuating unrealistic beauty standards that negatively impact body image and self-esteem, fostering a detrimental comparison culture, engaging in deceptive consumption practices (such as failing to disclose sponsored content or promoting counterfeit goods), and raising privacy concerns through data collection.61 While these behaviors generally erode trust, they can also contribute to an influencer's controversial appeal and notoriety among certain audiences.

• Psychological Principles and Following Controversial Figures: Cialdini's principles of influence can help explain why individuals might follow and be influenced by problematic figures.6 For example, a controversial influencer might still be perceived as an authority in a specific niche, or their "authentic" sharing of unpopular opinions might foster a sense of liking or connection. If such an influencer amasses a large following (social proof), this can draw in more people. The scarcity heuristic might also apply if their content is perceived as being at risk of censorship.

Some influencers may consciously cultivate a controversial or "problematic" persona because it is financially rewarding and helps build a distinct brand identity. This suggests a strategic manipulation of audience psychology and platform algorithms, where behaviors traditionally seen as negative are repurposed as engagement tools.

4.4 Why Audiences Follow: Vicarious Experiences, Psychological Needs, and Other Motivations

The decision to follow an influencer, especially one exhibiting non-traditional or problematic traits, is often rooted in the fulfillment of various psychological needs or other complex motivations.

• Relatability and Aspiration, Especially for Youth: Teenagers, in particular, follow influencers to find figures they can relate to or aspire to become, even if this leads to feelings of inadequacy when comparing themselves to curated online lives.63 Some influencers may even promote toxic behaviors like aggression or excessive risk-taking, which might appeal to certain adolescent desires for rebellion or excitement.63

• Curated Vulnerability and Gaslighting: Influencers are adept at using techniques like perfectly curated content, feigned "vulnerable" moments designed to seem relatable, and even gaslighting (manipulating someone into questioning their reality) to maintain engagement despite problematic aspects of their persona or content.63

• Sense of Acceptance for Vulnerable Individuals: For children and young people who feel isolated, rejected, or excluded, influencers who promote certain views—even harmful ones—can offer a sense of acceptance and community if those views align with a group they wish to join.42 Sharing these views can provide a pathway to perceived friendship and belonging.

• Vicarious Experience and Expression: Followers may derive satisfaction from vicariously experiencing the influencer's lifestyle, travels, or successes, especially if these are beyond their own reach. This "vicarious expression" allows for a form of identification and connection through the influencer's storytelling.30

• Fulfillment of Emotional and Social Needs through PSRs: As discussed previously, parasocial relationships with influencers can provide comfort, companionship, entertainment, and emotional support, fulfilling genuine psychological needs.22 This strong emotional bond can lead followers to overlook, forgive, or even defend an influencer's problematic behaviors if the perceived connection and the fulfillment derived from it are sufficiently strong.

• Fear of Missing Out (FOMO) and Narcissistic Identification: The fear of missing out (FOMO) has been linked to problematic social media use, particularly among individuals with narcissistic traits. Followers may engage with certain influencers, including narcissistic ones, to stay constantly connected and avoid feelings of social exclusion.57

• Anti-Establishment Sentiment and Vicarious Rebellion: For some audience members, following controversial influencers who openly defy norms or challenge authority can be a form of vicarious rebellion.49 If followers feel constrained by societal expectations or distrustful of mainstream institutions, aligning with a "rebellious" influencer can be empowering or validating. While "vicarious rebellion" is noted as a dysfunctional motivator for individuals entering counseling professions 64, the underlying principle of deriving satisfaction from another's defiant acts could plausibly extend to follower motivations.

The success of influencers who exhibit a lack of formal education or engage in less acceptable social behaviors points towards a modern iteration of the "flawed hero" or "anti-hero" archetype. Audiences may be drawn to individuals who achieve success despite or perhaps because of their non-conformity. Their perceived "realness," which might include traits like selfishness or extreme outspokenness, can contrast sharply with traditionally polished public figures, making them appear more authentic or relatable to those disillusioned with conventional success narratives or societal norms. Their highly vocal nature, even if deemed less acceptable by some, can be interpreted as a form of strength, honesty, or defiance. This suggests a potential shift in what certain audience segments consider aspirational or trustworthy, challenging traditional notions of leadership and role modeling.

Furthermore, there's a complex dynamic where less acceptable, highly vocal, and sometimes selfish behaviors can generate controversy. This controversy, in turn, often drives engagement (as seen with "rage-baiting" 15). Engagement is frequently rewarded by platform algorithms with increased visibility.65 This enhanced visibility can lead to greater potential for financial success and social attraction in the form of follower growth. This creates a feedback loop where problematic behavior can become economically and socially reinforced, potentially incentivizing and amplifying less desirable social behaviors within the digital ecosystem.

It is also crucial to recognize the subjectivity of what is deemed "acceptable." What one segment of the population considers less acceptable, another might view as perfectly fine or even desirable. The highly niche nature of many online communities 66 allows influencers to cultivate dedicated followings who share their specific values and worldview, even if these fall outside mainstream norms. Within such a community, behaviors like "selfishness" might be reframed as "self-care" or "assertiveness," and a "lack of formal education" might be interpreted as being "untainted by establishment thinking" or possessing valuable "street smarts." This implies that influencer success is often about finding and deeply resonating with a specific sub-audience whose values may differ significantly from broader societal expectations, contributing to the echo chamber effects often associated with social media.

Ultimately, the success of problematic influencers is a co-constructed phenomenon. It is not solely about the influencer's actions but also deeply intertwined with the psychological needs, vulnerabilities, and motivations of their audience. Understanding this dynamic requires looking at both the supply (the influencer's content and persona) and the demand (the audience's reasons for engagement).

Section 5: The Ecosystem: Platforms, Algorithms, and the Influencer Landscape

The success and operational dynamics of social media influencers are inextricably linked to the technological and structural environment in which they operate. Social media platforms, their algorithms, and specific features play a pivotal role in shaping content visibility, facilitating monetization, and defining the very nature of modern influence.

5.1 Role of Social Media Algorithms in Content Visibility and Creator Success

Social media algorithms are powerful, often opaque, systems that dictate what content users see, thereby profoundly impacting creator visibility and potential for success.65 These algorithms are generally designed to maximize user engagement (such as likes, comments, shares, and watch time) and enhance the overall user experience by providing a personalized and relevant content stream, encouraging users to spend more time on the platform.65

• Instagram's Algorithm: Focuses on factors like user relationships (accounts interacted with frequently), user interests (content types previously engaged with), and timeliness of posts. It tends to favor content that garners high engagement quickly and often gives an initial boost to creators who are early adopters of new platform features like Reels and Stories.65

• TikTok's Algorithm: Known for its highly personalized "For You" page, TikTok's algorithm considers metrics like video watch time, completion rates, user interactions (likes, comments, shares, follows), and the use of trending sounds and hashtags. Its design can facilitate rapid audience growth for creators whose content aligns with these engagement signals.39

• YouTube's Algorithm: Employs a sophisticated recommendation system that analyzes viewers' watch history, search queries, subscriptions, and engagement patterns (likes, dislikes, comments, watch time) to suggest relevant videos. Search Engine Optimization (SEO) through relevant keywords in titles, descriptions, and tags is also crucial for discoverability.65

• X/Twitter's Algorithm: Prioritizes tweets from accounts that users follow and interact with, as well as content deemed likely to be of interest based on past engagement history and trending topics.65

• Twitch's Algorithm: Primarily prioritizes live streams that are actively being viewed and interacted with by a significant number of users. Factors like concurrent viewers, chat activity, and overall engagement during a live broadcast are key.65

Creators must navigate these algorithmic landscapes by producing content that is not only authentic to their brand but also optimized for discoverability and engagement. This involves understanding platform-specific best practices, such as using relevant hashtags, engaging with trending topics or sounds, optimizing posting times, and consistently producing high-quality content.65 However, maintaining authenticity while chasing algorithmic favor is a delicate balance; while algorithm-friendly strategies are essential for visibility, genuine connection with the audience and content that reflects the creator's true values are paramount for long-term success and trust.65 Algorithms, therefore, act as powerful kingmakers and gatekeepers, shaping not only individual influencer careers but also broader social and cultural trends by amplifying certain types of content and voices.

5.2 Platform-Specific Features Facilitating Influencer Dynamics and Monetization

Social media and creator platforms offer a suite of features that facilitate direct interaction, community building, and various monetization strategies, profoundly shaping influencer-audience dynamics.

• Direct Interaction Tools:

• Live Streaming: Platforms like Twitch, Instagram, TikTok, Facebook, and YouTube offer live streaming capabilities, often integrated with features like real-time chat, Q&A sessions, interactive polls, and mechanisms for audiences to send virtual gifts, tips, or badges.38 These tools foster immediate, dynamic engagement, strengthen parasocial relationships by creating a sense of presence and direct access, and provide direct monetization opportunities.

• Likes, Comments, Direct Messages (DMs): These fundamental social media features create interactive feedback loops, allowing followers to engage with influencer content and, in some cases, directly with the influencer.21 They simulate social bonding and are crucial for building and maintaining parasocial connections.

• Community Building Tools:

• Membership and Subscription Tiers: Platforms such as Patreon, Gumroad, and native features on YouTube, Instagram, Facebook, Twitch, and Discord allow influencers to offer tiered memberships or subscriptions.34 These tiers typically provide subscribers with exclusive content (e.g., behind-the-scenes footage, early access, members-only posts), special perks (e.g., custom emotes, badges), or deeper interaction, fostering loyalty and providing a recurring revenue stream.

• Dedicated Community Spaces: Influencers can create dedicated hubs for their communities using features like Discord servers, Facebook Groups, Patreon community feeds, or Skillshare class discussion forums.38 These spaces allow for more focused interaction, role assignments, content organization, and community moderation.

• Gamification and Digital Collectibles: Some platforms, like TopFan, offer gamification elements to reward engagement and allow for the creation and sale of digital collectibles (e.g., NFTs), adding another layer of interaction and monetization.40

• Monetization Platforms and Tools:

• E-commerce Integrations: Link-in-bio storefronts (e.g., The Leap) and AI-powered digital product builders enable influencers to sell products directly.69 Platforms like Shopify allow influencers to set up their own online stores.72

• Course Platforms: Influencers can monetize their expertise by creating and selling online courses on platforms like Thinkific, Udemy, or Skillshare.38

• Affiliate Marketing Networks: Marketplaces like Amazon Affiliate Program and ShareASale provide infrastructure for influencers to earn commissions by promoting products.69

• Influencer Marketing Platforms: Tools such as AspireIQ, CreatorIQ, and Upfluence connect influencers with brands for collaborations and help manage campaigns.38

• Analytics and Performance Tracking: Comprehensive analytics tools (e.g., Google Analytics, Social Blade, Iconosquare, and platform-native analytics) are crucial for influencers to understand their audience, track content performance, and demonstrate value to brand partners.72

These platform features are increasingly blurring the lines between content consumption, community participation, and commercial transactions. Live streams, for example, seamlessly integrate entertainment (content) with real-time audience interaction (community) and opportunities for direct financial support through virtual gifts or links to purchase featured products (commerce).39 Similarly, shoppable posts on platforms like Instagram turn visual content directly into e-commerce opportunities.8 Exclusive communities built around subscriptions offer members privileged content and interaction, directly monetizing the community itself.40 This integration creates a more immersive, and potentially more persuasive, consumption experience for audiences. For influencers, it opens diverse revenue streams but also intensifies the challenge of balancing authentic connection with commercial objectives.

5.3 Comparing Social Media Influencers (SMIs) to Traditional Celebrities and Opinion Leaders

Social media influencers represent an evolution in the landscape of public figures and persuasion, sharing some characteristics with traditional celebrities and opinion leaders but also exhibiting distinct differences.

• Credibility and Trust: SMIs are often perceived by their audiences, especially younger demographics like Gen Z, as more credible, authentic, and relatable than traditional celebrities.9 While the endorsement power of traditional celebrities often stems from their widespread fame, recognition, and established status (e.g., in film or sports), SMIs frequently build credibility through niche expertise, consistent content creation in a specific area, and a perceived "ordinariness" or similarity to their followers.12

• Audience Connection and Engagement: SMIs typically foster higher levels of engagement due to their direct and frequent interaction with followers via platform features like comments, DMs, and live chats, cultivating a sense of community.12 Traditional celebrities often have a more distant relationship with their fanbase.

• Parasocial Relationships (PSRs): The development and maintenance of PSRs are paramount for the reputational capital and endorsement effectiveness of SMIs.75 A weak PSR can be significantly more detrimental to an SMI's influence than to that of a traditional celebrity, whose credibility may be rooted more in their offline achievements and status.75

• Risk and Affordability for Brands: Collaborating with SMIs, particularly micro-influencers and nano-influencers, is often perceived as less risky and more affordable for brands compared to securing endorsements from A-list traditional celebrities.12

• Evolution of Opinion Leadership: The concept of opinion leadership, as originally described in Lazarsfeld's Two-Step Flow (TSF) theory, involved individuals who consumed mass media and then relayed and interpreted messages for their less-attentive peers.76 Social media influencers can be seen as a new type of opinion leader, sometimes termed "Proximal Mass Opinion Leaders" (ProMOLs), who cultivate influence within self-built digital networks, often through a perceived interpersonal style despite reaching large audiences.76 They build trust through mechanisms like perceived authenticity, relatability, and the development of PSRs.78 While the TSF model requires adaptation for the digital age, its core idea of mediated influence remains relevant.76 The Elaboration Likelihood Model (ELM) also helps in understanding SMI persuasive impact, which can occur via a central route (persuasion through the quality of arguments) or a peripheral route (persuasion through cues like attractiveness, popularity, or source credibility).77

SMIs are not an entirely novel phenomenon but rather a digitally augmented and often more personalized iteration of older influence patterns. They leverage many of the same fundamental psychological principles of persuasion (e.g., authority, liking, social proof) as traditional figures of influence.2 However, they adapt these principles to the unique affordances of social media, particularly through the cultivation of stronger, more interactive parasocial relationships and a greater emphasis on perceived authenticity and relatability.

The table below offers a comparative overview:

Feature/Dimension	Traditional Celebrities	Social Media Influencers (SMIs)	Key Snippet ID(s)
Basis of Credibility	Fame, status, recognized achievements (e.g., acting, sports)	Niche expertise, perceived authenticity, relatability, consistency of content, "lived experience"	12
Audience Connection	Often distant, based on admiration of public persona	Closer, more interactive, often perceived as peer-like or friend-like (PSRs)	12
Primary Mode of Interaction	Mass media appearances, limited direct fan interaction	Direct engagement via social media (comments, DMs, live streams), community building	12
Perceived Authenticity	Can be low, endorsements often seen as purely transactional	Generally higher, especially for micro/nano-influencers; authenticity is key to trust	9
Cost-Effectiveness (Brands)	Typically very high cost	Variable; micro/nano-influencers can be highly cost-effective	12
Reliance on PSRs	Less critical; influence often stems from status	Paramount for reputational capital and endorsement effectiveness	75
Risk Factor (Brands)	High (potential for major scandals)	Variable; often lower with smaller influencers, but controversies can still occur	12

This comparison highlights that while both groups exert influence, the mechanisms and perceptions surrounding SMIs are distinctly shaped by the interactive and relational nature of social media.

Section 6: Synthesis and Concluding Insights

The ascent of social media influencers to positions of significant financial success and social attraction is a complex phenomenon rooted in foundational principles of social influence, evolving economic models, potent psychological drivers, and a dynamic technological ecosystem. This report has dissected these components, revealing how influencers, even those with non-traditional backgrounds or exhibiting controversial behaviors, can achieve remarkable impact.

6.1 Recapping the Complex Interplay of Factors

The capacity of influencers to shape audience thoughts and actions is grounded in established models of social influence, such as conformity, compliance, and obedience.1 Principles like Cialdini's "weapons of influence" (reciprocity, social proof, authority, liking, scarcity, commitment/consistency, and unity) are actively, if sometimes unconsciously, deployed to persuade followers.2

Their financial success is driven by a maturing creator economy where diverse revenue streams—from brand partnerships and affiliate marketing to merchandise sales and direct fan subscriptions—are strategically managed.7 This economic landscape increasingly values demonstrable ROI and authentic engagement over mere follower counts.8

The psychological attraction to influencers is multifaceted. Central to this is the formation of parasocial relationships (PSRs), where followers develop one-sided bonds of intimacy and friendship.16 Perceived authenticity and relatability are paramount in fostering these connections and building trust.5 Influencers also tap into fundamental human needs for autonomy, competence, and relatedness (Self-Determination Theory) 5, and engage audiences through social comparison mechanisms, which can be both aspirational and detrimental.19 The cultivation of strong communities further solidifies loyalty and engagement, often leveraging principles of social identity.34

Finally, the entire influencer ecosystem is shaped by social media platforms and their algorithms, which act as gatekeepers of visibility and success.65 Platform-specific features facilitate direct interaction, community building, and monetization, further blurring the lines between content, community, and commerce.38

6.2 Addressing the Central Paradox: Success Despite Perceived Flaws

The core of the inquiry lies in how influencers achieve success despite, or sometimes because of, a perceived lack of formal education or the exhibition of less acceptable social behaviors.

• Lack of Formal Education as an Asset:A lack of formal education, rather than being a consistent detriment, can be reframed or perceived in ways that enhance an influencer's appeal. It can foster relatability and homophily, especially with audiences who do not prioritize traditional academic credentials or may view them with skepticism.14 The narrative of success achieved through "lived experience" or "street smarts" can be more compelling and appear more authentic than advice from formally trained experts, particularly if the influencer's journey resonates with overcoming adversity.27 An influencer who consistently creates valuable content in a niche can build expertise and authenticity through practice, regardless of formal qualifications.13 The "self-made" narrative, powerfully conveyed through authentic storytelling, often becomes more persuasive than a traditional resume, embodying resilience and non-conventional achievement.46 This taps into an anti-intellectual or anti-establishment sentiment where practical wisdom is valued over institutionalized knowledge.49

• Less Acceptable Social Behaviors (Highly Vocal, Selfishness, Controversy):

• Vocal and Controversial Personas: Being highly vocal, even if it involves less socially acceptable pronouncements or controversial stances, can be perceived as a sign of authenticity or an "unfiltered" persona. This can attract audiences weary of overly curated or politically correct content, or those actively seeking alternative viewpoints that challenge mainstream narratives.6 An anti-establishment stance can, in itself, be a powerful brand.

• Selfishness and Narcissism: While clinically negative, traits associated with narcissism, such as grandiosity, extreme self-focus, or an unwavering confidence, can be captivating for some audience segments.56 These displays might fulfill certain follower psychological needs, such as vicarious empowerment or admiration for perceived strength. The very act of fame-seeking, common among influencers, is linked to narcissistic tendencies.50

• The "Outrage Economy" and Strategic Provocation: Behaviors like "rage-baiting"—intentionally creating content to provoke anger—are often deliberate strategies to maximize engagement.15 In an online economy where attention is currency and algorithms often reward any form of high engagement, highly vocal and controversial content, even if "less acceptable," can be financially and socially rewarding.54

• The Power of Social Proof and Parasocial Bonds: Once an influencer, even a controversial one, amasses a large following (social proof), this can attract further followers.2 Furthermore, if strong parasocial relationships have been established, followers may be more inclined to overlook, forgive, or even defend problematic behaviors due to the perceived emotional connection and the fulfillment they derive from the relationship.17 The "flawed hero" archetype may emerge, where success despite or because of non-conformity becomes appealing.

The success of influencers exhibiting these traits suggests that for certain audiences, traditional markers of credibility (like formal education) are secondary to perceived genuineness, even if that genuineness includes negative or controversial characteristics. This challenges conventional notions of what constitutes an influential or trustworthy public figure. However, there is a threshold; behaviors like overt deception (e.g., undisclosed ads, promoting harmful products) generally erode trust across broader audiences, indicating that not all problematic behavior is tolerated or beneficial in the long run.61

6.3 The Evolving Nature of Influence in the Digital Age

The influencer phenomenon signals a significant evolution in how influence is cultivated and consumed. The clear demarcations between entertainment, community interaction, commercial activity, and information dissemination are becoming increasingly porous. Authenticity remains a prized commodity, yet its definition is fluid and context-dependent, capable of encompassing "authentic flaws" or even "authentic controversy." The power dynamics are also in constant flux, with influencers, their audiences, commercial brands, and the underlying social media platforms all vying for agency and benefit within this complex ecosystem. The rise of the "outrage economy" suggests that the digital environment may, at times, inadvertently incentivize and amplify behaviors that are less socially desirable, creating a feedback loop where problematic conduct can be both economically and socially reinforced.

6.4 Considerations for Audiences, Brands, and Influencers

This complex landscape presents distinct considerations for all participants:

• For Audiences: A heightened need for critical media literacy is essential. Understanding the persuasive tactics employed by influencers, recognizing the constructed nature of online personas, and managing the psychological impacts of social comparison and parasocial relationships are crucial for navigating this environment healthily.

• For Brands: The focus should shift towards partnerships with genuinely authentic influencers whose values align with the brand's ethos. Looking beyond superficial metrics to assess true community engagement and potential ROI is vital. Brands must also carefully weigh the potential benefits and significant risks associated with collaborating with controversial or "edgy" influencers.

• For Influencers: The ongoing challenge lies in maintaining perceived authenticity while navigating monetization opportunities. Ethical responsibilities towards their audience, particularly concerning transparency and the promotion of products or lifestyles, are paramount. The long-term sustainability of influence strategies built on controversy versus those built on genuine community and value provision also warrants careful consideration.

In conclusion, the success of social media influencers, even those lacking traditional credentials or exhibiting unconventional behaviors, is not arbitrary. It is a product of their ability to tap into fundamental social and psychological needs, leverage sophisticated economic models, and navigate a technologically mediated environment that often rewards visibility and engagement above all else. The "flaws" or "unacceptable behaviors" highlighted are sometimes integral to their appeal, reframed as authenticity, relatability, or a defiant stance against convention, resonating powerfully with specific audience segments in an increasingly fragmented and subjective digital world. However, this success often walks a fine line, with the potential for trust to be easily broken if perceived authenticity gives way to overt deception or harm.

Works cited

1. Three Types of Social Influence: Conformity, Compliance, and ..., accessed May 16, 2025, https://peterberryconsultancy.com/social-influence/

2. Social influence - Wikipedia, accessed May 16, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_influence

3. us.sagepub.com, accessed May 16, 2025, https://us.sagepub.com/sites/default/files/07_heinzen_social_influence_0.pdf

4. Social Influence Theory - Consensus Academic Search Engine, accessed May 16, 2025, https://consensus.app/questions/social-influence-theory/

5. Decoding the Credibility of Influencers Among College Students., accessed May 16, 2025, https://digitalcommons.cwu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1355&context=ijurca

6. The Psychology of the Modern-Day Social Media Influencer ..., accessed May 16, 2025, https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/consciously-creating-your-soul-life/202401/the-psychology-of-the-modern-day-social-media

7. Breaking Down the Creator Economy | Sprout Social, accessed May 16, 2025, https://sproutsocial.com/insights/guides/creator-economy/

8. Influencer Marketing and Affiliate Marketing - PartnerCentric, accessed May 16, 2025, https://partnercentric.com/blog/influencer-marketing-a-centerpiece-of-any-2025-performance-marketing-plan/

9. 20 Surprising Influencer Marketing Statistics - Digital Marketing Institute, accessed May 16, 2025, https://digitalmarketinginstitute.com/blog/20-influencer-marketing-statistics-that-will-surprise-you

10. A Model of Influencer Economy - ResearchGate, accessed May 16, 2025, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/356846134_A_Model_of_Influencer_Economy

11. A Comprehensive Overview of Micro-Influencer Marketing: Decoding the Current Landscape, Impacts, and Trends - ResearchGate, accessed May 16, 2025, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/379063876_A_Comprehensive_Overview_of_Micro-Influencer_Marketing_Decoding_the_Current_Landscape_Impacts_and_Trends

12. Social Media Influencers or Celebrity Endorsement ... - Sway Group, accessed May 16, 2025, https://swaygroup.com/social-media-influencers-new-celebrities/

13. New Research Unveils Key Strategies for influencer authenticity ..., accessed May 16, 2025, https://news.gsu.edu/2025/02/20/influencer-authenticity/

14. Impact of Social Media Influencers on Customer Engagement and ..., accessed May 16, 2025, https://www.mdpi.com/2071-1050/15/3/2744

15. 'Maybe you'll realise what you have is good enough': Why ... - BBC, accessed May 16, 2025, https://www.bbc.com/culture/article/20250107-why-the-pushback-against-influencers-is-growing

16. Parasocial interaction - Wikipedia, accessed May 16, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parasocial_interaction

17. Parasocial Relationships: The Nature of Celebrity Fascinations ..., accessed May 16, 2025, https://www.findapsychologist.org/parasocial-relationships-the-nature-of-celebrity-fascinations/

18. Full article: Parasocial Relationships and Self-Disclosure ..., accessed May 16, 2025, https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/10496491.2025.2466585?af=R

19. The Psychology of Influencer Culture: How Social Media Influencers Impact Behavior and Self-Perception - Emoneeds, accessed May 16, 2025, https://www.emoneeds.com/the-psychology-of-influencer-culture/

20. Influencer marketing - Wikipedia, accessed May 16, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Influencer_marketing

21. A Parasocial Effect: When online platforms create illusions of ..., accessed May 16, 2025, https://www.milwaukeeindependent.com/explainers/parasocial-effect-online-platforms-create-illusions-closeness-authenticity/

22. Parasocial Relationships & its Influence on Followers - DiVA portal, accessed May 16, 2025, http://www.diva-portal.org/smash/get/diva2:1934697/FULLTEXT01.pdf

23. 7 Different Types of Parasocial Relationships & How to Cope, accessed May 16, 2025, https://www.marriage.com/advice/relationship/parasocial-relationships-types/

24. scholarspace.manoa.hawaii.edu, accessed May 16, 2025, https://scholarspace.manoa.hawaii.edu/bitstreams/ec82fbeb-809f-4b10-85c3-b71a6b890244/download

25. All Users Are Equal, but Some Users Are More Equal Than Others: Exploring the Psychology of Users That Follow Social Media Influencers - ResearchGate, accessed May 16, 2025, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/376370913_All_Users_Are_Equal_but_Some_Users_Are_More_Equal_Than_Others_Exploring_the_Psychology_of_Users_That_Follow_Social_Media_Influencers

26. A Proposed Model of Self-Perceived Authenticity of Social Media Influencers - Cogitatio Press, accessed May 16, 2025, https://www.cogitatiopress.com/mediaandcommunication/article/viewFile/4765/2514

27. The Importance of Authenticity in Influencer Marketing| Sprout Social, accessed May 16, 2025, https://sproutsocial.com/insights/authenticity-in-influencer-marketing/

28. Full article: Perfect imperfection: Vulnerability in influencer ..., accessed May 16, 2025, https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/0267257X.2025.2495330?src=

29. Negotiating authenticity: experiences of student influencers on ..., accessed May 16, 2025, https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/13676261.2024.2419085

30. Why are consumers following social media influencers on Instagram ..., accessed May 16, 2025, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/353960792_Why_are_consumers_following_social_media_influencers_on_Instagram_Exploration_of_consumers'_motives_for_following_influencers_and_the_role_of_materialism

31. www.shs-conferences.org, accessed May 16, 2025, https://www.shs-conferences.org/articles/shsconf/pdf/2024/05/shsconf_iclcc2024_03008.pdf

32. Social Comparison Theory and Social Media | Newport Academy, accessed May 16, 2025, https://www.newportacademy.com/resources/empowering-teens/theory-of-social-comparison/

33. The Influencer Impact - Children and Screens, accessed May 16, 2025, https://www.childrenandscreens.org/learn-explore/research/the-influencer-impact-a-parents-guide-to-influencers/

34. Online Brand Community Platform & Features | Enhance Your Brand, accessed May 16, 2025, https://hivebrite.io/online-brand-community-platform-features

35. "You Belong with Me: Examining the Relationship between ..., accessed May 16, 2025, https://digitalcommons.liberty.edu/doctoral/6610/

36. Full article: Travel influencers and their social identity: a phenomenological approach, accessed May 16, 2025, https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/13683500.2024.2419554

37. (PDF) Fandom and Wellbeing - Exploring the Psychological Link, accessed May 16, 2025, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/391081269_Fandom_and_Wellbeing_-_Exploring_the_Psychological_Link

38. 20 best content creator platforms to grow your following - Gelato, accessed May 16, 2025, https://www.gelato.com/blog/content-creator-platforms

39. The Best Platforms that Pay Content Creators in 2025 - Podcastle, accessed May 16, 2025, https://podcastle.ai/blog/platforms-that-pay-content-creators/

40. TopFan's Ultimate Fan Club Platform for Influencers, accessed May 16, 2025, https://www.topfan.com/apps/influencers-patreon-alternative/

41. How to Make Money as an Influencer: The Complete Guide to ..., accessed May 16, 2025, https://blog.clickmeeting.com/make-money-as-an-influencer

42. The influencers of influencers | NSPCC, accessed May 16, 2025, https://www.nspcc.org.uk/keeping-children-safe/online-safety/online-safety-blog/2023-05-16-the-influence-of-influencers/

43. Influencer Credibility: A Model of Personality Traits in Predicting Followers' Behavior - Qeios, accessed May 16, 2025, https://www.qeios.com/read/6WJ9RC

44. (PDF) THE ROLE OF INFLUENCER AUTHENTICITY AND BRAND ..., accessed May 16, 2025, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/387302346_THE_ROLE_OF_INFLUENCER_AUTHENTICITY_AND_BRAND_TRUST_IN_SHAPING_CONSUMER_BEHAVIOR_STRATEGIES_TO_ENGAGE_GENERATION_Z

45. Street Smarts vs. Book Smarts: The Figured World of Smartness in ..., accessed May 16, 2025, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/225512096_Street_Smarts_vs_Book_Smarts_The_Figured_World_of_Smartness_in_the_Lives_of_Marginalized_Urban_Youth

46. How to Build Authentic Leadership Through Storytelling - HSI, accessed May 16, 2025, https://hsi.com/blog/how-to-build-authentic-leadership-through-storytelling

47. Crafting A Leadership Narrative: Embracing Personal Identity, accessed May 16, 2025, https://www.keirabrinton.com/crafting-a-leadership-narrative-embracing-personal-identity

48. Influencer Politics - DiVA Portal, accessed May 16, 2025, https://umu.diva-portal.org/smash/get/diva2:1924268/FULLTEXT01.pdf

49. Dave Smith-Douglas Murray debate highlights Right-wing fault lines ..., accessed May 16, 2025, https://unherd.com/newsroom/dave-smith-douglas-murray-debate-highlights-right-wing-fault-lines/

50. Full article: Unravelling fame-seeking motive and narcissism: the ..., accessed May 16, 2025, https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/0144929X.2025.2462258?src=

51. Social Media influencers and the decline of intellectualism, accessed May 16, 2025, https://www.newarab.com/opinion/social-media-influencers-and-decline-intellectualism

52. The influencer-intellectual tactic and social media advertisements ..., accessed May 16, 2025, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/386077256_The_influencer-intellectual_tactic_and_social_media_advertisements_How_PragerU_advances_partisan_knowledge

53. How content creators profit from rage-baiting - Marketplace, accessed May 16, 2025, https://www.marketplace.org/episode/2024/12/30/how-content-creators-profit-from-rage-baiting

54. The outrage economy: Why social media makes everything worse, accessed May 16, 2025, https://www.dailykos.com/stories/2023/7/15/2181179/-The-outrage-economy-Why-social-media-makes-everything-worse

55. Dark triad - Wikipedia, accessed May 16, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dark_triad

56. The Dark Triad Personality: Its role in Consumer Psychology ..., accessed May 16, 2025, https://www.neuroscienceof.com/branding-blog/personality-dark-triad-laura-detter-consumer-psychology

57. Why narcissists overuse social media—and how mindfulness can help, accessed May 16, 2025, https://www.psypost.org/why-narcissists-overuse-social-media-and-how-mindfulness-can-help/

58. Narcissism and Social Networking Sites: The Act of Taking Selfies, accessed May 16, 2025, https://www.csus.edu/faculty/m/fred.molitor/docs/selfies%20and%20narcissism.pdf

59. Narcissists and Positions Of Power and Influemce, accessed May 16, 2025, https://narcissisticbehavior.net/narcissists-and-positions-of-power-and-influence/

60. Narcissistic Leaders and Their Victims: Followers Low on Self-Esteem and Low on Core Self-Evaluations Suffer Most, accessed May 16, 2025, https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC5884951/

61. (PDF) The Dark Side of Social Media Influencers: A Research ..., accessed May 16, 2025, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/388110732_The_Dark_Side_of_Social_Media_Influencers_A_Research_Agenda_for_Analysing_Deceptive_Practices_and_Regulatory_Challenges

62. Understanding bad influencers | Kidslox, accessed May 16, 2025, https://kidslox.com/guide-to/bad-influencers/

63. Likes and Lies: The Effects of Influencers on Teens | Psychology ..., accessed May 16, 2025, https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/power-in-relationships/202503/likes-and-lies-the-effects-of-influencers-on-teens

64. CPSY 400 Flashcards | Quizlet, accessed May 16, 2025, https://quizlet.com/70564709/cpsy-400-flash-cards/

65. The Role of Social Media Algorithms in Shaping Creator Success, accessed May 16, 2025, https://mozaic.io/the-role-of-social-media-algorithms-in-shaping-creator-success/

66. Influencer marketing niches: Niche Influencers vs: Mass Appeal ..., accessed May 16, 2025, https://fastercapital.com/content/Influencer-marketing-niches--Niche-Influencers-vs--Mass-Appeal--Which-Strategy-Works-Best.html

67. Influencer Marketing Niches - HireInfluence.com, accessed May 16, 2025, https://hireinfluence.com/blog/influencer-marketing-agency-niches/

68. Social Media Algorithms And Influencer Reach - Meegle, accessed May 16, 2025, https://www.meegle.com/en_us/topics/influencer-economy/social-media-algorithms-and-influencer-reach

69. 20 Best Influencer Monetization Platforms and Tools (2024) - Thinkific, accessed May 16, 2025, https://www.thinkific.com/blog/influencer-monetization-platforms/

70. The Impact of Influencer Motives and Commonness Perceptions on Follower Reactions Toward Incentivized Reviews, accessed May 16, 2025, https://eprints.whiterose.ac.uk/166156/3/Manuscript%20IJRM.pdf

71. Prevalent User-centered Monetization Techniques in Social Media - EconJournals.com, accessed May 16, 2025, https://econjournals.com/index.php/irmm/article/download/14005/7069/31953

72. Which Tools Do Social Media Influencers Use? - Software Career ..., accessed May 16, 2025, https://www.tealhq.com/software/social-media-influencer

73. The Best Influencer Marketing Platforms: Features, Functions ..., accessed May 16, 2025, https://www.chicexecs.com/2025/01/07/the-best-influencer-marketing-platforms-features-functions-and-strategies/

74. (PDF) Exploring the Perception of Influencers Vs. Traditional ..., accessed May 16, 2025, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/318477583_Exploring_the_Perception_of_Influencers_Vs_Traditional_Celebrities_Are_Social_Media_Stars_a_New_Type_of_Endorser

75. The development of reputational capital – How social media ..., accessed May 16, 2025, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/361217716_The_development_of_reputational_capital_-_How_social_media_influencers_differ_from_traditional_celebrities

76. Revisiting opinion leadership in the digital realm: Social media influencers as proximal mass opinion leaders | Request PDF - ResearchGate, accessed May 16, 2025, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/391338983_Revisiting_opinion_leadership_in_the_digital_realm_Social_media_influencers_as_proximal_mass_opinion_leaders?_tp=eyJjb250ZXh0Ijp7InBhZ2UiOiJqb3VybmFsIiwicHJldmlvdXNQYWdlIjpudWxsLCJzdWJQYWdlIjoib3ZlcnZpZXcifX0

77. jatosjournal.org, accessed May 16, 2025, https://jatosjournal.org/files/jatos/65c56a7f-af95-4116-87f2-ef1b7a3a612b.pdf

78. The Two-Step Flow Theory in the Digital Age (2005–2025): An ..., accessed May 16, 2025, https://www.preprints.org/manuscript/202505.0192/v1

79. The Two-Step Flow Theory in the Digital Age (2005–2025): An Analytical Literature Review - Preprints.org, accessed May 16, 2025, https://www.preprints.org/frontend/manuscript/20c003e919efb18108a430a8bb36621b/download_pub

80. Selling trust: when social media influencers mislead their followers, accessed May 16, 2025, https://hanoitimes.vn/selling-trust-when-social-media-influencers-mislead-their-followers.643500.html

When likes go rogue: advertising standards and the malpractice of ..., accessed May 16, 2025, https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/17577632.2024.2361517